AFCE

TSR Dynasty Draft Grades

TSR Dynasty Draft Grades
class="post-date-wrap left relative post-date-mob">

Unlike other expert draft graders, I ensure there’s an even balance of passing grades and failing grades. Let’s take a look at how it went down.


Archer: 2 day-1 starters and a Derrick Henry replacement. Grade A
1.7 WR Zay Flowers – Ravens
2.5 TE Sam LaPorta – Lions
2.6 RB Tyjae Spears – Titans

Mars: Late rounds value pick extraordinaire. No high picks going in, but chances are one of those late round WR’s breaks out. Grade B+
2.2 TE Michael Meyer – Raiders
3.1 QB CJ Stroud – Titans
3.2 WR Marvin Mims – Broncos
3.7 RB Roschon Johnson – Bears
3.8 WR Cedric Tillman – Browns
3.9 WR Kayshon Boutte – Pats

North: Finfan going back-to-back RB at 1 & 2 made for what would be a top class of picks look meh. Grade C
1.3 WR Jaxon Smith-Njigba – Seahawks
2.3 WR Rashee Rice – Cheifs
3.3 RB Chase Brown – Bengals

Hoodie: This is as close to coming out of a draft empty handed as it gets. Grade D-
2.4 RB Kendre Miller – Saints
3.4 RB Israel Abanikanda – Jets
3.5 WR Jayden Reed – Packers
3.6 WR Michael Wilson – Cardinals

Dud: Trusting UNC players is never going to get high marks from me. Surprisingly I would have liked to see a reach for Kincaid here. Grade C
1.5 WR Jordan Addison – Vikings
2.7 WR Josh Downs – Colts

Link: By name alone Tank Bigsby is easily the best RB in this class. Also a fan of both Johnston and Kincaid’s value. Keenan Allen isn’t getting any younger. Grade A
1.4 WR Quenton Johnston – Chargers
1.6 TE Dalton Kincaid – Bills
2.9 RB Tank Bigsby – Titans

Finfan: After a surprising, but shrewd, move taking RB1 and RB2 Finfan went full boom or bust on Richardson. For a team that feasts on 33 year old Travis Kelce numbers a developmental TE made more sense to me at 2.1. Grade A-
1.1 RB Jahmyr Gibbs – Lions
1.2 RB Bijan Robinson – Falcons
2.1 QB Anthony Richardson – Colts

Thumbs: Grade F
N/A

CGC: Mingo is the Panthers only WR right now. Other than that, this guy has no idea what he’s doing. Grade D+
1.8 WR Jonathan Mingo – Panthers
1.9 RB Devon Achane – Fins
2.8 QB Bryce Young – Panthers

Noss: Noss comes away with the Kenneth Walker handicap who some think would be RB1 on many teams and Mr. Irrelevant. Grade C
1.10 RB Zach Charbonnet – Seahawks
2.10 WR Jalin Hyatt – Giants
3.10 RB Deuce Vaughn – Cowboys

More in AFCE

Week 4: Gameday

Brian GrothSeptember 29, 2024

Week 3: Gameday

Brian GrothSeptember 22, 2024

Week 2: Gameday

Brian GrothSeptember 15, 2024

Week 1: Gameday

Brian GrothSeptember 8, 2024

Week 2 Recap

cgc5783August 19, 2024

Week 1 Recap

cgc5783August 12, 2024